Steroids in MMA
Which MMA Fighter Will Test Positive For Steroids Next?

If MMA Is About Respect, Why Have We Turned Against Georges St. Pierre?


(Photo courtesy of Getty Images)

By Seth Falvo

My first thought following the main event of UFC 167 was that Georges St. Pierre had a concussion. Granted, “hack journalist” is a far cry from doctor, but he was displaying symptoms that should make any sports fan concerned. He lost track of what round it was, he had trouble forming words, and the completely vacant look in his eyes was disturbing — even for a guy as stoic as GSP.

If this thought occurred to Dana White and the media members in attendance, they did a damn fine job of hiding it. You know what happened by now: White claimed St. Pierre “owed” everyone an immediate rematch, the media attempted to steer Georges St. Pierre away from talking about the signs of brain damage he has been experiencing — despite St. Pierre’s best attempts to do otherwise — and White eventually talked to the champ in private before downplaying everything that St. Pierre admitted to experiencing as much as possible.

As Stand and Bang accurately wrote, “White’s behavior [was] so transparently morally repugnant that there’s no reason to spend time pedantically analyzing it.” He wanted to pressure GSP back into the cage as quickly as possible, because the longer the champion has to reflect upon the damage that he’s done to himself, the less likely he is to return to the sport. Yet there are actually fans — and plenty of them — who managed to take the bait. There are fans who buy the ideas that St. Pierre somehow “owes” it to anyone to accept a rematch against Johny Hendricks, that he’s obligated to return to the cage immediately, that Dana White’s dangerously-capitalistic treatment of his most influential champion is completely acceptable.

And let’s not forget the most disgusting part about this: These fans are delusional enough to say with a straight face that MMA is about “respect.”

I’m really not sure how we ever managed to accept the “mixed martial arts is about respect” fallacy in the first place; pretending that the earliest MMA events were complex rituals of respect — as opposed to sporting events and entertainment — is adorably delusional. Perhaps it caught on due to the revisionist history that all martial arts suffer from, perhaps due to a misunderstanding of Bushido. Or perhaps it’s just reframing caused by the cognitive dissonance required to care about the people you enjoy watching injure themselves. Regardless of how it got here, it’s at the point where even fighters like Houston Alexander believe that MMA is about respect, which is laughable on its own, and downright dangerous in the aftermath of UFC 167.

No human being “owes” someone harm to their own mind and body. That I have to explain this to people who claim that their sport is built around respect is more than a little disturbing, and their rationalizations only paint a scarier picture. There’s the argument that Georges St. Pierre “chose to be a fighter,” as if he also chose to give up his right to retire whenever he wants (which he was hinting at well before Saturday night) and his right to look out for his own health when he made that decision. Others are slightly more humane, and instead argue that he simply “owes” it to us to get back in the cage within the next few months, because second-impact syndrome and brain damage are things that should be taken as lightly as possible. I’m sure the medical community will be thrilled to learn that.

Respect does not come with conditions. You can’t only respect someone when they do what you want them to. If you do, you aren’t “respecting” them, you’re manipulating them, and that’s exactly what abusive spouses do to their victims. “Georges, you know I respect you, baby. It’s just that I love watching you fight soooo much and you made me soooo mad by wanting to take time off that I didn’t have a choice but to publicly humiliate you like that. Please don’t leave me, please give me (or in this case, Johny) one more chance.”

I’m not saying that I don’t think Hendricks was robbed on Saturday night. And I’m also not saying that I wouldn’t watch a rematch. But I am saying that if Georges St. Pierre decides to stick around for one more fight, I want him to do so only after he feels he’s had enough time to recover from Saturday night and make an educated decision. He’s built his entire life around being the ideal Zuffa employee and perfect ambassador for our sport, despite never needing us as much as we’ve needed him. If you think this sport is about respect, you’ll wait patiently, too.

Comments

  1. Signal to Noise: UFC 167′s best and worst – MMA Fighting | MMA NEWS Says:

    Tue, 11/19/13 - 02:14


    [...] St-Pierre retains top welterweight spot in Times MMA rankingsLos Angeles TimesIf MMA Is About Respect, Why Have We Turned Against Georges St. Pierre?CagepotatoUSA TODAY -Sherdog.comall 1,048 news [...]
  2. Quote of the Day: Georges St. Pierre Will Never Fight Again Unless Freddie Roach Is in His Corner | MMA Bookmarks Says:

    Wed, 11/20/13 - 01:17


    [...] not sure if you’ve heard about this yet but UFC welterweight champion Georges St. Pierre hung onto his belt this past Saturday at UFC 167 with a controversial split decision win over Johny Hendricks and then [...]
  3. Georges St-Pierre retains top welterweight spot in Times MMA rankings – Los Angeles Times | MMA NEWS Says:

    Wed, 11/20/13 - 03:04


    [...] but not without controversySI.comA union’s low blow to MMA fightersNew York PostUSA TODAY -Cagepotatoall 1,094 news [...]
  4. CagePotato PSA: Dear MMA Media, Stop Asking for Dana White’s Opinion on Every Last Goddamn Subject | MMA Bookmarks Says:

    Thu, 11/21/13 - 06:17


    [...] recently, White’s comments regarding Georges St. Pierre’s “retirement” and what he “owes” the fans spurned somewhat of a media backlash, with both fans and critics questioning everything from [...]
  5. CagePotato PSA: Dear MMA Media, Stop Asking for Dana White’s Opinion on Every Last Goddamn Subject | Fight Pins | MMA Pins Says:

    Fri, 11/22/13 - 04:37


    [...] recently, White’s comments regarding Georges St. Pierre’s “retirement” and what he “owes” the fans spurned somewhat of a media backlash, with both fans and critics questioning everything from [...]
  6. Lorenzo Fertitta Walks Back Dana White’s Burial of Georges St-Pierre: “GSP Doesn’t Owe Us Anything” | MMA Bookmarks Says:

    Fri, 11/22/13 - 08:17


    [...] had to say yesterday to Ariel Helwani, regarding Dana White’s now-infamous rant about what Georges St-Pierre “owes” the UFC following last weekend’s fight against Johny [...]
  7. Lorenzo Fertitta Walks Back Dana White’s Burial of Georges St-Pierre: “GSP Doesn’t Owe Us Anything” | MMA and UFC News Says:

    Sun, 11/24/13 - 05:24


    [...] had to say yesterday to Ariel Helwani, regarding Dana White’s now-infamous rant about what Georges St-Pierre “owes” the UFC following last weekend’s fight against Johny [...]
  8. If MMA Is About Respect, Why Have We Turned Aga... Says:

    Mon, 11/25/13 - 04:47


    [...]   [...]
  9. jalia parsnip Says:

    Sun, 12/01/13 - 08:44


    If MMA Is About Respect, Why Have We Turned Against Georges St. Pierre? | Cagepotato... Whispering Misty...
  10. The Four Most Likely Scenarios to Emerge From Georges St. Pierre’s Upcoming Press Conference | Fight Pins | MMA Pins Says:

    Tue, 12/10/13 - 08:37


    [...] the biggest reason fans (and Dana White) turned against St. Pierre following UFC 167 was not due to the belief that he was ducking a Hendricks rematch, but rather [...]
  11. OmW54iMUCi OmW54iMUCi Says:

    Sun, 02/09/14 - 02:08


    Woman of Alien... Great function you have got completed, this great site is absolutely amazing with superb data. Time is God's way of preserving every thing from going on directly....
  12. CagePotato Ban: Pretending to Care About the Fighters When Your Actions Prove You Don’t | MMA Bookmarks Says:

    Thu, 02/20/14 - 11:21


    [...] we’re the only people who care about them, either. But rather, this is a call to the fans who throw a fighter under the bus because he wants to treat his injuries, who think nothing of a former WEC champion only being offered $17k to fight, and who cheer for an [...]
  13. Acheter e-liquide Says:

    Sat, 04/05/14 - 01:57


    Thanks,... It is a pleasure going through your post. I have bookmarked you to check out new stuff from your side....
  14. urlman cow Says:

    Tue, 04/08/14 - 02:48


    Thorn of Girl... Superb information could be found on this internet web site....
  15. cozy cove Says:

    Thu, 08/28/14 - 10:17


    The Ships's Voyages... I think engineering just can make it worse. Now there is a channel to never ever care, now there wouldn't be a opportunity for them to find....
  16. p ¥×¥é¥À ?i¹È ¤¯ Says:

    Fri, 10/31/14 - 08:31


    p ¥×¥é¥À ?i¹È ¤¯... 157cm?50kg ¤ª¤Ê¤«¤¬×î½ü¤Ý¤Ã¤Á¤ã¤ê¤·¤Æ¤­¤¿¤Î¤ÇُÈ뤷¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£M¤òُÈ뤷¤Þ¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¤·¤á¤Ä¤±¸Ð¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤ª¤Ê¤«¤Î¤Ý¤Ã¤Á¤ã¤ê¤Ï¤½¤Î¤Þ¤ó¤Þ¤Ç¤Ï¤¤¤Æ¤â?仯¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç²ÐÄî¤Ç¤·¤¿¡£...
  17. cat 4 brother Says:

    Sun, 01/18/15 - 02:33


    The Ships's Voyages... I think technological know-how just makes it worse. Now there is a channel to in no way care, now there will not be considered a possibility for them to find out....
  18. blue ofica Says:

    Tue, 01/20/15 - 12:00


    The Ships's Voyages... I think engineering just makes it even worse. Now there's a channel to never ever treatment, now there won't be considered a prospect for them to find....
  19. Around The Interweb – Tuesday, November 19th | World Wide Interweb Says:

    Sat, 11/21/15 - 05:01


    [...] If MMA Is About Respect, Why Have We Turned Against Georges St. Pierre? [...]
CagePotatoMMA