Steroids in MMA
Which MMA Fighter Will Test Positive For Steroids Next?

Is it Possible to Fix The UFC Hall of Fame Induction Process?

(Well? Photo courtesy of Getty Images.)

By the time that this is published, the ceremony that will make Stephan Bonnar an official member of the UFC Hall of Fame will be underway. Bonnar’s resume includes an 8-7 UFC record, a flawless 0-0 record in UFC title fights, two failed drug tests and the significance of his TUF Finale bout against Forrest Griffin – a fight so important to UFC history that it has its own Wikipedia page. Bonnar also is on good terms with Dana White, which is arguably the most important criterion for induction into what is supposedly the UFC’s highest honor.

Regardless of how you feel about Bonnar’s induction, that last sentence should make you feel uncomfortable. A company that already has trouble convincing non-fans that it isn’t glorified professional wrestling selects people into its hall of fame the same way that the WWE does – by allowing one person to dictate who is worthy of the honor. Both halls have some debatable inductions. Both halls have some notable omissions. Neither hall is taken seriously by most fans of either sport.

While many articles have been written about how Bonnar’s induction highlights everything that’s wrong with the UFC Hall of Fame selection process, pretty much none of them offered any solutions. Below you’ll find a few suggestions to fix the hall, as well as reasons that they may not work. Let’s start off with the most obvious fix…

Let the Journalists Vote

Why it would work - Because that’s pretty much what every legitimate Hall of Fame does. It may not make too much of a difference as to who gets inducted (more on that in a second), but at least then we’ll be able to take the hall seriously.

Why it wouldn’t work – Or will we? If the only journalists who are allowed to vote are those who are on good terms with the UFC – and unwilling to do anything to jeopardize this – the results will inevitably be just as biased as those adorable “official UFC rankings.

Let the Fans Vote

Why it would work - Because halls of fame are for the fans in the first place, so why not let them decide who they want in them? Also, current UFC Hall of Famer Tito Ortiz seems to believe it would work. Via MMA Junkie:

I think [the Hall of Fame selection process] should be a fan vote,” Ortiz said. “That’s what it should really come down to. The fans should consider how much they’ve known the person, how much they’ve watched them fight and so forth and just how much the fighter had significance in the sport in general. I think that’s the answer.”

Why it wouldn’t work - How’s this for irony: Ortiz doesn’t think that Bonnar deserves to be in the hall of fame, but thinks that allowing the fans to induct their favorite the most worthy fighters is the solution. If you’re even slightly familiar with the voting process for the NBA All Star Game, then this requires zero explanation. If you aren’t familiar with it – and were too lazy to click the two links in this section – then let’s just say that guys like Bonnar would only be more likely to be inducted into the hall if the fans were allowed to vote.

Mark Cuban’s Weighted Fan Vote

Why it would work – The problem with letting the people vote on the Internet is that anyone with an unhealthy obsession with an athlete and too much free time can significantly affect the outcome, regardless of how often they even watch the sport. In an attempt to fix this, Dallas Mavericks owner Mark Cuban offered a solution – count votes cast in arenas during events twice as much as Internet votes. This not only rewards fans who are loyal enough to buy tickets to events, but also helps ensure that votes from educated fans aren’t immediately cancelled out by votes from people looking to troll the election. Win/win.

Why it wouldn’t work – At best, counting arena votes twice as much as Internet votes is like putting a Band-Aid on a gaping wound; if you’re trolling an election online, you aren’t just voting once. At worst, keep in mind that it’s estimated that as much as 60% of a sporting event’s live gate comes from casual fans, which means that the Affliction clad oaf who thinks Brock Lesnar is the best fighter on the planet would now have twice as much influence on the outcome as the hardcore MMA fans watching the event from home.

Use Statistics

Why it would work – If the current problem facing the UFC Hall of Fame is human bias, then adding even more humans to the mix isn’t going to fix anything. Let’s just take a look at the stats – Win/loss record, takedown percentage, strikes landed; etc. – and let the numbers determine who really belongs in the hall of fame.

Why it wouldn’t work – The fighter who has landed the second-most strikes in UFC history, the third-most takedowns and left the organization with a 14-3-1 UFC record isn’t a member of the UFC Hall of Fame. Is this proof that we need to use statistics to determine who should be in the hall?

If you said yes, then congratulations – you just inducted Jon Fitch.

Screw it, Let’s Just Start a Hall of Fame

Why it would work – It wouldn’t.

So how do you think the inductions should be handled? Let us know in the comments section.


Cagepotato Comments

Showing 1-25 of comments

Sort by : Show hidden comments
Reatele- July 9, 2013 at 7:42 am
as Dorothy responded I'm surprised that a mother able to profit $8597 in a few weeks on the computer. have you seen this website
kayla1231- July 7, 2013 at 11:17 am
If you think Gladys`s story is impossible..., 5 weaks-ago my son in-law basically brought home $5442 just sitting there a ninteen hour week an their house and they're co-worker's step-mother`s neighbour has done this for 3 months and got paid over $5442 part time on there pc. applie the steps at this website...
RwilsonR- July 7, 2013 at 7:01 am
I'm with cman. For one thing, it is early in the sport, and at this stage you have to take into account not just records, but people who helped build the sport and the company (it is the UFC HOF, not the MMA HOF, after all). The majority of the fans right now don't have any MMA knowledge pre-Bonnar. Also, perhaps due to it being a young sport, or perhaps due to the times in which the sport has come of age, but the bar for being an "MMA journalist" is incredibly low. No Columbia School of Journalism degree required. No grinding it out for a few decades writing articles for local papers to progressively wider distribution before you get your shot at a nationally syndicated gig. Nope. You have a keyboard and give Go Daddy $20, you're suddenly a journalist. And the "journalists" in MMA are as biased as Dana White. Some are clearly UFC schills, but others are pissed they aren't getting the same golden shower from Dana, and can't say a positive word about him or the UFC. So right now, let the decision rest with the guys in charge. It's their company. If the sport continues to grow, maybe one day there will be an MMA HOF. If it stays a bit stagnant, it will probably be a niche audience like this forver, and you aren't going to please them anyway.
anderson wanderlei paulo thiago alves silva- July 6, 2013 at 7:02 pm
Bonnar is Barry bonds. But he sucks
algiersheadkick504- July 6, 2013 at 4:41 pm
How the fuck is Ariel hewani relevant in mma or even allowed to discuss mma...if I ever see that bozo fuck I'm throwing him a beat down then dealing with a lawsuit and a shit load of laywers probably related to him...but I will be satified
cman- July 6, 2013 at 3:47 pm
Early as this sport is... they should have the right to induct whomever they feel helped them get to where they are. Thse who jumped ship for a payday, or spent half their time breaking down the brand, or generally said fuck the fans can pete rose their asses right on down the road. FYI, letting the Media vote i much more disturbing to me than letting those who have been behind the scenes decide. Seriously, Kevin Lowe having a voice??? Maggie Hendricks? Ariel?? Fuck that, they think they actually understand the sport as is, now i have to let them decide whose a legend? Bad enough half the time if i want news less than 24 hours old i have to read them give a fashion report along with it.
CheckHisPee- July 6, 2013 at 3:42 pm
Just let me decide, Bonnar's out, done deal.
towelie- July 6, 2013 at 3:07 pm
they dont give a shit about the legitimacy of their Hall of Fame. it's just another thing to attract attention to their brand and somewhat honor the fighters that helped them get where they are.
Fried Taco- July 6, 2013 at 2:00 pm
The CP Hall of Fame would be the only one I ever had a shot at. :-(
The12ozCurls- July 6, 2013 at 3:31 pm
Haven't I done ENOUGH for your fragile ego! lol
The12ozCurls- July 6, 2013 at 12:12 pm
A world where Cal Worsham AND Iron Mike Sharpe are NOT in their respective Halls of Fame - is a world that I don't want to live in. God bless BOURBON for an escape from the true injustices of this cruel cruel world.
crappiefloper- July 6, 2013 at 11:38 am
Why would you mention that giant fuckstick Lesner? Now I'm just gonna be pissed off all day. Fuck Lesner! Him and John kitna should be torn apart by a pack of wolves, I would induct the wolves into DW's,"hall of fame"
algiersheadkick504- July 6, 2013 at 11:26 am
Bonners career went limb the second time he lost to griffin and got popped for roids. Anyone popped fir cheating (twice at that) should not be in any hall of fame
mousemeat- July 6, 2013 at 11:11 am
Remember, It's the 'Hall of Fame', not the 'Hall of Achievement'.

The average person is who fame relies on, and more people have heard of Stephan Bonnar than they have Mark Coleman.